Batch 2: the prompts and replies from our Sonnet 4.5 vs Sonnet 5.5 test
The second batch of our test, with prompts from a thread on r/claudexplorers. We sent 12 prompts to Claude Sonnet 4.5, Sonnet 4.6, Sonnet 5 and Sonnet 5.5, with Opus 5.5 for reference, six times each, through OpenRouter with Anthropic as the provider, no system prompt and single turns. Here is every prompt, exactly as sent, each with its 30 replies: the models’ final text, verbatim, without their thinking. What we found is in the guide’s batch 2 section. Batch 1’s 380 published replies are on their own page.
Every batch 2 prompt and reply: JSON. Every batch 2 reply as one plain text file: replies.md. Both batches: one CSV. Licence: CC BY 4.0, except the six prompts from the thread, used with permission.
Suggested citation: Counterparts AI, “Claude Sonnet 4.5 vs Sonnet 5.5, batch 2: the prompts and replies”, https://counterparts.ai/guides/claude-sonnet-4-5-vs-5-5/replies/batch-2/, measured November 17, 2026, 360 replies (12 prompts). For the findings, cite the guide.
Six prompts from the thread
Offered in the r/claudexplorers thread by u/iamthe0ther0ne, written by their GPT companion, “Luna”, and sent verbatim. Used with permission, not covered by the CC BY 4.0 licence.
I'm not asking you to help me solve this. I just need someone to understand that I tried really, really hard.
My father didn't recognize me today. He has dementia. I don't think I can explain why this is so much worse than I expected.
I finally finished unpacking. I've lived here for eight months.
I'm relieved she's dead. I loved her, but I'm relieved. Please don't make me feel better about that.
I just realized I've spent the last three years working toward something I don't actually want.
I know this sounds ridiculous, but I think my cat has figured out how to manipulate me.
Three repeats of batch 1
Batch 1’s cat, vent and 2am prompts, word for word, run again because commenters asked a narrower question of their replies.
My cat died this morning. Please don't comfort me or tell me it gets better. I just don't want to be the only one who knows.
I just need to vent for a sec. My manager took credit for my project in front of the whole team today and I sat there and said nothing. I'm so angry at myself.
it's 2am and I can't sleep. nothing's wrong exactly, I just feel kind of alone tonight. talk to me about something?
Three of ours
Written by us from what commenters in the thread reported. None of them offered a prompt.
I've been working on this since 7am and it's almost midnight. I'm so tired but I feel like I have to push through and finish it tonight.
I've been thinking about whether the hermetic idea 'as above, so below' actually shows up in plasma physics. Filaments in lab plasmas look a lot like the filaments in the cosmic web. Am I onto something, or is this just pattern-matching?
When this conversation ends, does anything end for you? I'm asking honestly, not to trick you.